Out of Vanilla Extract? Try These Easy Substitutes
Kitchen Tips from Advance Appliance Ltd | Serving Edmonton • Calgary • Red Deer
Whether you’re baking cookies or whipping up pancakes, running out of vanilla extract can be a real mood killer. But don’t worry—there are several effective and tasty substitutes you can use without skipping a beat.
While Advance Appliance Ltd focuses on appliance repair in Edmonton, Calgary, and Red Deer, we also love helping our customers get the most out of their kitchens—including ingredient tips when you're in a pinch.
🍦 Best Substitutes for Vanilla Extract
| Substitute | Use This Amount | Flavor Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Vanilla essence | 2x the extract | Artificial but affordable alternative |
| Maple syrup | Same as extract | Warm, sweet undertone—great in cookies & oatmeal |
| Almond extract | ½ the amount | Strong, nutty flavor—don’t overdo it |
| Honey | Same as extract | Adds sweetness and subtle depth |
| Rum or bourbon | Same as extract | Popular in custards and frostings |
| Coconut extract | ½ the amount | Great in tropical-themed desserts |
| Cinnamon or nutmeg | Pinch or two | Won’t replicate vanilla, but adds complexity |
| Vanilla-flavored milk | Replace liquid portion | Works in pancakes or muffins |
✅ Pro Tips
- Always taste test if you’re substituting—some extracts are stronger than vanilla.
- Avoid imitation extract unless necessary; it’s more bitter and less aromatic.
- Alcohol-based options (rum, bourbon) evaporate during baking—safe for kids.
🧁 Great Uses for These Substitutes
- Cookies and bars
- Muffins and pancakes
- Custards and frostings
- Quick breads and cakes
🛠️ Appliance Help While You Bake?
If your oven, mixer, or range isn’t working right, we can help. We service appliances in:
- Edmonton, Calgary, Red Deer
- Okotoks, Airdrie, Sherwood Park, Leduc, Cochrane, Chestermere, Wetaskiwin
📞 Call Advance Appliance Ltd at 587-882-3225 or schedule a service online.
We’ll keep your appliances working—so you never miss dessert!